I need to talk

So for all of you anime watchers who have seen hundreds of anime like me or maybe just a lot do you get that feeling where you maybe want to rewatch a anime but don't because it doesn't hit the same.
Like I remember watching Demon Slayer as my first anime / *(I started watching anime later on but watched a lot lol) * and I remember how I stayed up all night watching the every episode that was out at the time and then I watched JJK, AOT, One Piece, and then every single romance anime to exist, but like now I don't get that same feeling.